Crumbly buttery bars of shortbread make afternoon tea time something to look forward to. This version of shortbread is easy to make (hence, ‘fail-proof’ in the title), and can also be given as a thoughtful gift.
How to make fail-proof shortbread: key tips
This recipe uses a whole 250g block of butter to achieve its buttery texture. Make sure that you soften it to room temperature before beating, so that it will combine easily with the other ingredients.
In step 3, only combine the flours with the creamed butter mixture until just combined. You won’t want to stir too much or the overworked flour will make your shortbread too dense. Also, knead it just until the dough becomes smooth.
Once rolled out, you can cut your shortbread into fancy shapes, or just simple bars, it’s up to you. If you need to re-roll the dough, keep any handling to a minimum so the dough doesn’t become overworked.
Browning is an enemy of shortbread, as the aim is to achieve a tender crumb, so only bake until the biscuits are very light golden around the edges.
Key ingredients in this fail-proof shortbread recipe
Butter maketh the shortbread. Whether you use salted or unsalted butter is up to you. See more about this in the recipe notes below.
Cornflour gives shortbread that melt-in-your-mouth texture, as it reduces the gluten development of the dough, which leads to a more delicate and tender crumb.
Caster sugar dissolves more quickly than regular white sugar, making the sweetness in the shortbread more consistent. Meanwhile, vanilla essence adds richness and a greater depth of flavour to the sugary buttery dough.
Try some more of our delicious shortbread recipes, as well as this kid-friendly chocolate shortbread.
This recipe was originally submitted by avly, a member of the Australia’s Best Recipe community. Introduction and additional recipe notes by Natasha Shaw.